CASE & BV2 Analysis Old vs. New Rules
Result of one 200-point ammunition explosion
Simplified structural comparison: standard internal structure, side-torso ammunition explosion, no cascading explosions, no critical-hit effects, and no armor modeling. The old-rules case assumes an explosion large enough to destroy both locations. The new-rules cases model caps of 20 internal damage without CASE, 10 with CASE, and 1 with CASE II.
2026 CASE rules: Old vs. New comparison
Compare six representative weights, all three protection levels, and standard versus XL engines. Select Inner Sphere or Clan to display the OLD rules on the left and NEW rules on the right. Results assume one large ammunition explosion in a side torso, with full internal structure before detonation and no additional critical hits. These are deterministic scenarios, not survival probabilities.
Inner Sphere — Old rules
Inner Sphere — New rules (2026)
Clan standard CASE is normally integrated with no mass or critical-slot cost; “Clan no CASE” is a hypothetical counterfactual. The left panel always shows OLD rules; the right panel always shows NEW rules. For old-rule results, the explosion is assumed to be large enough to destroy an unprotected CT or a standard-CASE-protected side torso; CASE II retains its one-point structural protection. “Operational” means no CT destruction and fewer than three engine hits from this explosion alone; other effects are excluded.
What survives at each tonnage?
These numbers show side torso / center torso internal structure remaining after one large explosion under the new rules. A zero means that location is destroyed. Use the OLD vs. NEW comparison above to see how the outcome changed.
| Weight | Before explosion Side / CT | No CASE Side / CT | Standard CASE Side / CT | CASE II Side / CT |
|---|
Without CASE, even an intact CT is destroyed. CASE saves the CT, but not the side torso.
Without CASE, the CT survives but takes internal damage. Standard CASE can now save the side torso.
An intact CT survives if the side torso absorbs at least one point of the 20-point explosion.
An intact CT has 21 structure and survives even if all 20 damage points reach it.
An unprotected, intact side torso has exactly 20 structure and is destroyed by the explosion.
An unprotected, completely intact side torso survives with just 1 structure point. Prior damage removes this advantage.
Why does engine type matter?
No engine critical slots in the side torso. Losing that torso is damaging, but does not automatically disable the engine.
Three engine slots per side torso. Losing one side torso disables the engine. Saving the torso with CASE can therefore be decisive.
Two engine slots per side torso. Losing it causes two engine hits and +10 heat per turn, but not automatic three-hit shutdown.
Surviving locations can still suffer critical hits. These examples isolate one explosion and do not predict full-game survival.
At unchanged BV2, who gained the most?
Direct answer: In the modeled single-explosion scenario, no configuration becomes mechanically worse under the new rules. Some improve dramatically; others gain little or no meaningful operational benefit. That is a relative value comparison, not proof that any design is officially overpriced or underpriced in BV.
The CT is still destroyed by the explosion. It gains no survival benefit in this worst-case example.
The CT survives an explosion that previously destroyed the 'Mech. The side torso is still lost.
The CT survives, but the lost side torso still destroys three engine slots and disables the 'Mech.
Instead of sacrificing the side torso, CASE can preserve its structure, weapons, and attached arm, subject to critical hits.
CASE can now save the side torso and prevent the three automatic engine hits that previously disabled the 'Mech.
Preserving the torso avoids two automatic engine hits and their +10 heat penalty.
A fully intact side torso survives one explosion with only 1 structure point. Earlier damage or another explosion can change the outcome.
Only 1 internal damage per explosion, plus reduced explosion-generated critical-hit risk. The benefit varies with the specific design.
What became worse value? Nothing in this model got weaker in absolute terms. However, unprotected IS XL designs at 55–95 tons improved less than CASE-protected XL designs, so they may be less attractive relative to those alternatives at unchanged BV. A precise BV adjustment cannot be established from this single-event comparison.
Actual ammunition-vulnerability BV penalty
The TechManual BV2.1 calculation subtracts 15 defensive-rating points per qualifying explosive ammunition critical slot, then multiplies the defensive rating by the unit's Defensive Factor. On a typical side-torso ammunition slot, CASE removes this penalty for an IS standard or light engine; the published formula still applies it to an IS XL engine even with CASE. Clan designs with integrated CASE generally do not take that side-torso penalty. This is not a fixed “CASE equipment BV cost.”
How the Defensive Factor is calculated: The calculator uses the highest target movement modifier (TMM) from running or jumping. Running TMM depends on the number of hexes moved; jumping uses the distance-based TMM plus 1. The resulting movement-based Defensive Factor is 1 + (maximum TMM ÷ 10). For example, 5/8/5 movement gives running TMM +3 and jumping TMM +3 (+2 for five hexes, plus 1 for jumping), so the factor is 1.3. A 5/8/8 jumper instead has jumping TMM +4 and factor 1.4.
| Configuration (side torso ammo) | Penalty before factor | Final defensive BV penalty |
|---|
BV calculator shows the ammunition vulnerability subtraction only and assumes no defensive-rating floor. Movement is used to estimate the Defensive Factor; special movement systems and other defensive modifiers are not included. It does not recompute the complete unit BV, engine, armor, weapon BV, or skill modifiers. CASE II and non-side-torso placement require checking the applicable protection and damage-transfer provisions.
Limitations and final conclusions
- One explosion is not a complete battle. Initial detonation probability depends on armor penetration, critical-slot layout, ammunition remaining, and exposure. Cascading explosions and follow-up attacks can defeat an otherwise surviving torso.
- Rear armor matters. For explosions exceeding the cap, unprotected damage can remove the rear armor of the final surviving torso; CASE and CASE II can each inflict up to 10 rear armor damage if their protected torso survives. This display deliberately focuses on internal structure.
- CASE II remains distinct. Its one-point internal cap and −1 explosion-caused critical-hit modifier reduce the chance of damage to components and subsequent ammunition explosions, even where standard CASE already preserves the torso.
- Engine criticals and equipment value matter. Saving a side torso is especially consequential for IS XL engines, but a surviving torso can still suffer engine or weapon critical hits. A Clan XL with two engine hits remains operational but suffers serious heat penalties.
- BV conclusions are directional, not a recalibration. At unchanged BV, the modeled outcomes show improved relative value for several configurations, particularly 55–95t standard-engine unprotected designs and CASE-protected XL designs. No category is demonstrably overpriced in BV from these calculations alone. Quantifying that requires real record sheets and battle-level modeling.